The Potala Palace soars above Lhasa, thirteen stories of imposing redandwhite fortress topped with elaborately detailed Tibetan roofs. Inside the Dalai Lama's traditional winter home are tombs of his predecessors, two seventhcentury chapels, dozens of jewelencrusted statues and stupas, and hundreds of murals recording the lives of the former Himalayan kingdom's spiritual leadersoh, and rooms full of rubble, actors playing Buddhist monks, and a gift shop selling tourist trinkets (Lhasa beer, yak jerky) emblazoned with images of the site, which until 1959 was the seat of Tibet's government. It costs you five dollarsand your conscienceto get in the front door .
Across the world there are castles and churches, minarets and museums, burning ghats and ethnic ghettos, promenades and restaurants and riverbanks, taxi drivers, school teachers, tour guides, fruit vendors, street urchins, artists, government functionaries, underpaid doctors, and even college freshmen (and sophomores and juniors and seniors)many of them located in countries with repressive governments, internal strife, oneparty politics, stomachturning humanrights records, and a million other reasons to spend the summer in Florida. Maybe Palm Beach is out, too: Does anyone remember butterfly ballots and pregnant chads? Still, you can't just stay home. You may want Israel out of Jerusalem, or a Kurdistan carved from Turkey, or a Cuba free of Fidel, but you may also want to lounge on a Tel Aviv beach, eat authentic doner kebab, and smoke Cohibas until you vomit. You may dream of stringing up the Taliban by their beards, but wouldn't it be fun to hike the Hindu Kush? Deciding not just where to go but whether and how to go can be a heartwrenching process. As Amnesty International spokesman Alistair Hodgett puts it, "If you're driving on a road in Burma that's constructed through slave labor, are you personally uncomfortable with that? Or do you travel down it nonetheless, and try and use your experiences to come back informed about the country?" The U.S. government has an easy solution: If you're thinking of vacationing in Cuba, Libya, Iraq, North Korea, or several other nations with whom Washington is not on speaking terms, think again. You may be able to get an official license to go, often as part of an academic trip, but the ban on travel generally isn't so much diplomatic as economic. "It doesn't matter if you're buying a taco on the beach or using some sort of statesponsored travel agency for your ticket," says a spokeswoman for the U.S. Treasury Department. "A dollar spent in Cuba without a license is a violation of U.S. law." Criminal penalties range toyikes! 10 years in prison and $250,000 in fines. That is, if you're caught redhanded with a stamped passport and a plate of rice and beans.
One Is the Loneliest Number "I was one of those individualistic hotheads who thought, Oh, groups are for sissies," says Kevin Danaher, cofounder of Global Exchange, which runs socalled "reality tours" to more than a dozen countries, " Over the decades I learned that you get a lot more out of your money and out of the experience when you go with a group." "People have busy lives," he adds. "They're not going to drop everything to give you an hour interview about how their hospital works or something like that, but when we come in, you get access. If we take people to South Africa under apartheid, you want to have people meet a white government official who's going to give the arguments defending apartheid. If you take them to Cuba, you want them to meet people who trash Fidel and people who love Fideland people who don't give a damn one way or the other."
But one Global Exchange participant, Geoff Bederson, says his Cuban reality tour in 2000 failed in just that regard. The group stayed exclusively in luxury hotels, ate in fancy restaurants, and met with no one who wasn't "extremely positive" about the communist island, he says. Bederson, a 40yearold teacher at an alternative school in Anchorage, Alaska, says he had to get away from the group to find out the real level of oppression in the nation. Cuba boosters, he says, "always claim they have free medical care, and they dobut I met a university professor who earns about $25 a month but cannot afford medicine for her child." There's the biggest pitfall with any group that's going to take you off the beaten tourist track: politics. Many of the organizations that put reality tours together aim for balance, but their focus on poor and Third World nations seems to tilt them clearly to the left (not that there's anything wrong with that). There isn't really a rightwing version of Global Exchange, unless you count Club Med, most travel agents, or something like Abercrombie & Kent, the highend tour broker that will take you through the wilds of east Africa, stopping at every Hilton on the way. In a fundamental way, the group you choose will shape your impressions of a country and its people. "To get to the truth about what their level of freedom is, or their level of prosperity, is not easy," Bederson says. "Even if you're there, you may be blinded by your preconceptions."
Know Before You Go Her studies paid off. "For me, the Potala Palacegoing in, you just see how dead it is, and just how before the Chinese occupation there was so much life to these monasteries, and thousands and thousands of monks," she says, adding that she noticed more than just the deterioration of holy sites. "In the central marketplace, they had officers stationed at the corner. They had video cameras at the major monasteries. You kind of always knew that you were being watched and heard." Rajan's education didn't just cover recent historyshe learned from the tour leaders how not to make things worse. "We had to be very careful with our words," she says. "If we were in a Tibetan restaurant and mentioned the Dalai Lama . . . we had the power to get other people in trouble."
Mind Your Manners Still, you needn't bear mute witness to a country's woes. "Frankly, in countries in which it's appropriate, we would encourage people to raise those human rights issues that strike them in private conversation," says Amnesty's Hodgett. "I've heard anecdotally from people who've visited Turkey, where there's a lot of Western tourism but also a humanrights concern, that people have talked it through. And I think both sides benefit from those discussions. It's worth remembering that in a lot of societies in which there isn't free media, it's news for people to hear from tourists or travelers some of how their country's humanrights record is perceived externally." According to Hodgett, tourists also play a major role in bringing to light humanrights abuses around the world. "They happen to be visiting a remote site and observe a police crackdown or something else," he says. "People who've been tourists in Saudi Arabia have come back and actually have pretty valuable insights into what they've seen. They got stopped by the police, or an AfricanAmerican colleague was mistreated because that's routine in Saudi Arabia."
Follow the Money "You can't go to a country without leaving some money there," says Danaher, "but to equate that with 'If you spend money in some little café or in a hotel, does that go to the head of state?' I don't know. A piece of it does, but most countries have systems of taxation. Just like here, if you come to San Francisco, some of your money's going to go to our governor, who's a dick. But that's part of the structure." So while you can't keep every last peso, dinar and ringgit out of Big Brother's pockets, you can minimize his take by avoiding big hotels, fancy stores and restaurants, and large tourguide outfits, all of which often have direct or indirect ties to the government. In China, for example, the People's Liberation Army owns so many "regular businesses" that it's known as PLA Inc. Until 1998, when China tried to root out corruption by forcing the PLA to sell off its commercial enterprises, the military owned everything from pig farms to toy factories to nightclubs to hightech firms. As many as 1,500 hotels were under their control. Even now, the army has yet to divest itself of some major companies, including threestar hotels and cellphone systems. And don't imagine that, say, Beijing's Jinlang Hotel is now run by average folksmuch of the PLA's former holdings were transferred to the state. And you can bet that the Chinese government will be reaping a hefty profit from the 2008 Olympicsjust think of all those packed hotels, ticket commissions, and taxable cans of CocaCola . . . Still, you can't go around so frightened of funding a "bad government" that you end up sleeping on the street, or staying home altogether. "If you don't spend the twenty bucks staying overnight somewhere," says Hodgett, "in all likelihood, by the time you look at the government's share, and the share from that that goes to the military, which supports the humanrights violations, you're probably stiffing whoever the local merchant is who would've benefited from the economic activity." And in the end, the pittance the state collects will be far outweighed by what you gainexposure to new people, customs, and experiencesand by what you bring to those unfortunate citizens: a sense that the world has not forgotten them.
Unless . . . Think you can sidestep the regime and pump some cash into the local economy? Well, just to set foot in Yangon (formerly Rangoon), you've got to exchange $200 for special foreignexchange currency, a cut of which goes to youknowwho. Private companies that are unaffiliated with the military and that try to do business on the grassroots level often find themselves regretting success. Take the Mandalay Brewery. After Win Win Nu turned the failing venture around, transforming its beer into a hot commodityand making the company Myanmar's largest taxpayer, she was fired and eventually forced to withdraw her multimilliondollar investment. She has been fighting in the Myanmar and Asean legal systems since 1998; the International Court of Justice in the Hague agreed this summer to hear the case. And don't pretend that your presence as an emissary of the democratic West is going to teach the downtrodden Burmese about freedom. Woodrum says: "It's a silly assertion. The people of Burma have spoken strongly and clearly that they want democracy in the country. They gave Suu Kyi and the NLD 82 percent of the seats in the wouldbe parliament. It doesn't seem to me like they need to be educated." It's far from easy to gauge whether the travel boycott is helping the cause of a democratic Myanmar. With millions in foreign investment from the likes of Unocal, Pepsi, and Crate & Barrel, not to mention the cash that corrupt generals pocket from the heroin trade, Myanmar could probably care less whether it gets its cut from your two Ben Franklins. At the same time, the NLD has managed to reopen its offices, several large corporations (Kenneth Cole, Pottery Barn) have refused to do business in the country, and Suu Kyi has been in negotiations with the junta, though their outcome remains to be seen. Is this because principled tourists refused to fund repression? Or is it because conscientious travelers bore witness to humanrights abuses? There are no simple answers to these questionsand no one to answer them but you. Illustrations by J.F. Podevin |